What can we learn from the history of social network analysis?

When I joined Knight Lab as a student fellow six months ago, I became determined to make progress on a social network analysis (SNA) tool. As journalists we continually look to provide quality information through captivating perspectives and I believe that network data fulfills a part of that purpose in capturing the details of our society from a structural point of view.

But the fact is that network analysis is a tough problem to tackle. Knight Lab has had an interest in network analysis since at least 2012 and has had a microsite dedicated to the discipline for a year or two. In academia there’s even a phrase — Yet Another Social Network Analysis Tool (YASNAT for short) — that hints at just how difficult the problem is. In 2008, there were more than 60 SNA systems on a list maintained by the International Network for Social Network Analysis, which seems to have stopped tracking since. In this year’s InfoVis conference, there were 22 papers that evaluated user accuracy and speed of completing tasks using data visualizations; six of them dealt with network visualizations.

So to get my bearings before thinking about how to attempt to build a tool, I set out to first learn the history of SNA.

Jacob Moreno and the Birth of SNA

Dr. Jacob Levy Moreno

In The Development of Social Network Analysis, Linton C. Freeman, of UC Irvine, writes that Dr. Jacob Levy Moreno is the pioneer of SNA as we know it today, arguing on the basis of his work in the 1930s. There had been previous attempts to incorporate the abstractions of nodes and links to the study of human structures. But as it stood in 1938, Moreno’s work was the sole manifestation of all four features found in modern social network analysis, as laid out by Freeman:

  • It was motivated by a structural intuition based on ties linking social actors,
  • It was grounded in systematic empirical data,
  • It was heavily on graphic imagery, and
  • It relied on the use of mathematical and/or computational models.


Now, Dr. Moreno is one interesting dude. He had a medical degree, but he also had an over-the-top passion for telling stories. In his 1985 autobiography, he recalls a story of his birth on a ship on the 400th anniversary of the Expulsion of Jews from Spain. He also writes that, having "played God" throughout his life, he once formed a new religion as a student at the University of Vienna, believing that he "was on the planet to fulfill an extraordinary mission."

In the 1920s, he published The Theatre of Spontaneity, in which he began to develop the philosophies behind psychodrama and sociodrama. The two methods of psychotherapy involved role-playing in various theatrical settings, and Moreno believed that patterns of interactions among the patient-actors where spontaneity is crucial could provide insights practical to their everyday lives.

A sociogram produced by Jacob Moreno for his 1934 book Who Shall Survive?

In that book, he provided his first network diagrams, used to map actors and their interactions in scenes. Today, the most accessible topics in network analysis still involve the performing arts. The co-occurrence network of characters in the play Les Miserables is used as the primary example of structural data in the network analysis platform Gephi, as it also is in D3, the JavaScript data visualization library, and in Sigma.js, a graph drawing library. Similar co-occurrence networks for more than 700 movies have been visualized at moviegalaxies.com. IMDb is a source for many different forms of network data, from the collaboration network of actors (where two actors have a link if they starred in a movie together) to the reference network of movies (where two movies have a directed link if one makes a reference to the other). "Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon" is a popular game that challenges one to find, in the collaboration network, a path between an actor and Kevin Bacon with the shortest length. An online version is available at The Oracle of Bacon website.

From 1932 to 1934, at the Sing Sing prison in Ossining and the New York State Training School for Girls in Hudson, Moreno conducted studies to research group behavior, with methodological questionnaires he termed "sociometric tests." With his network diagrams and accompanying explanations, Moreno showed that the recent epidemic of runaways from the Hudson school could be explained through ties of attraction and repulsion that linked together and forced out those who had left. A 1933 article in The New York Times, titled Emotions Mapped By New Geography, covered his work at the school, showing that the study of networks has been of interest to journalists since its very beginning.

In his 1938 paper Statistics of Social Configurations, Moreno published a mathematical model of the tendency of individuals to link themselves to others non-uniformly. Famously in 1999, Albert-Laszlo Barabasi and Reka Albert independently modeled this process again, showing that the preference for attachment to highly connected actors leads to the emergence of a scale-free network, where the distribution of the number of connections each person has follows a power law, and thus few people have a lot of connections while a lot of people have few connections.

Journalistic uses of social structures

We’ve collected nine journalistic pieces that examine social structures and explain them with visualizations. I find that although most of them use systematic and empirical data, none of them utilizes mathematical methods.













Title Published on
The Stem Cell Wars New Scientist
Calderon Family Connections Los Angeles Times
Galleon's Web Wall Street Journal
Flip Investigation Saratosa Herald-Tribune
Web of Influence Dallas Morning News
Conversation About Guns on Twitter The Atlantic
A Web of GOP Influence NPR
Wen Family Empire New York Times
Clubs That Connect the World Cup New York Times

I have found such examples to be very useful in guiding myself through the terrain of social networks research. If you have run into any others, please tweet them at me @AllGoneMattHong.

Next steps

As I began to define the intersection of journalism and SNA in more organized terms, I found that deriving relationship strengths, important players, and patterns in network data might be putting the cart before the horse. What journalists need is a more efficient way to collect data and a better diagram to accompany it. To that end, Al Johri, Anne Li, and I will be chipping away at a tool we believe will assist in the creation of better visual stories with social network data. I’ll be writing a series of articles in order to share our research and development with the wider journalism community. My goal is to provide a solid scientific context for whatever we end up building and a narrow definition of what it is, what it isn’t, and where it fits in in the paradigm of SNA.

If you have an interest in networks or data stories, stay tuned for more.

About the author

Matt Hong

Undergraduate Fellow

Latest Posts

  • Introducing StorylineJS

    Today we're excited to release a new tool for storytellers.

    StorylineJS makes it easy to tell the story behind a dataset, without the need for programming or data visualization expertise. Just upload your data to Google Sheets, add two columns, and fill in the story on the rows you want to highlight. Set a few configuration options and you have an annotated chart, ready to embed on your website. (And did we mention, it looks great on phones?) As with all of our tools, simplicity...

    Continue Reading

  • Join us in October: NU hosts the Computation + Journalism 2017 symposium

    An exciting lineup of researchers, technologists and journalists will convene in October for Computation + Journalism Symposium 2017 at Northwestern University. Register now and book your hotel rooms for the event, which will take place on Friday, Oct. 13, and Saturday, Oct. 14 in Evanston, IL. Hotel room blocks near campus are filling up fast! Speakers will include: Ashwin Ram, who heads research and development for Amazon’s Alexa artificial intelligence (AI) agent, which powers the...

    Continue Reading

  • Bringing Historical Data to Census Reporter

    A Visualization and Research Review

    An Introduction Since Census Reporter’s launch in 2014, one of our most requested features has been the option to see historic census data. Journalists of all backgrounds have asked for a simplified way to get the long-term values they need from Census Reporter, whether it’s through our data section or directly from individual profile pages. Over the past few months I’ve been working to make that a reality. With invaluable feedback from many of you,......

    Continue Reading

  • How We Brought A Chatbot To Life

    Best Practice Guide

    A chatbot creates a unique user experience with many benefits. It gives the audience an opportunity to ask questions and get to know more about your organization. It allows you to collect valuable information from the audience. It can increase interaction time on your site. Bot prototype In the spring of 2017, our Knight Lab team examined the conversational user interface of Public Good Software’s chatbot, which is a chat-widget embedded within media partner sites.......

    Continue Reading

  • Stitching 360° Video

    For the time-being, footage filmed on most 360° cameras cannot be directly edited and uploaded for viewing immediately after capture. Different cameras have different methods of outputting footage, but usually each camera lens corresponds to a separate video file. These video files must be combined using “video stitching” software on a computer or phone before the video becomes one connected, viewable video. Garmin and other companies have recently demonstrated interest in creating cameras that stitch......

    Continue Reading

  • Publishing your 360° content

    Publishing can be confusing for aspiring 360° video storytellers. The lack of public information on platform viewership makes it nearly impossible to know where you can best reach your intended viewers, or even how much time and effort to devote to the creation of VR content. Numbers are hard to come by, but were more available in the beginning of 2016. At the time, most viewers encountered 360° video on Facebook. In February 2016, Facebook......

    Continue Reading

Storytelling Tools

We build easy-to-use tools that can help you tell better stories.

View More